IRA Tax Developments – Part 2
No Bankruptcy Exemption for Inherited IRAs. – Funds in IRAs and Roth IRAs are generally
exempt from forfeiture in bankruptcy proceedings, subject to a limitation of $1,000,000 or more. Unfortunately, though, the U.S. Supreme Court has now held that funds in inherited IRAs (and inherited Roth IRAs) are not entitled to any amount of exemption in bankruptcy. (Clark v. Rameker, __ U.S. __, 2014-1 U.S.T.C. ¶ 50,317.) See Chapter 5 of the treatise.
Boilerplate Cross-Collateralization Agreement Not Necessarily a Prohibited Transaction. – An IRA that is an individual retirement account will terminate on the first day of the taxable year of a loan transaction that is a prohibited transaction. However, the Sixth Circuit has held that the mere signing of a boilerplate cross-collateralization agreement (as a condition for opening an IRA) is not a prohibited transaction if the taxpayer has no other accounts that could be subject to the agreement. (Daley v. Mostoller, 717 F.3d 506 (6th Cir. 2013).) See Chapter 5 of the treatise for a discussion of IRAs.
Transactions Between an IRA Owner and an IRA-Owned Entity. – The tax law imposes substantial penalties on an IRA owner who engages in a “prohibited transaction” with his or her IRA (including potential taxable termination of the IRA). Prohibited transactions include loans, lines of credit, or guarantees from an IRA owner to an entity substantially owned by his or her IRA. (Peek v. Commissioner, 140 T.C. No. 12 (2013).)
Prohibited transactions also include compensation paid to an IRA owner for services rendered to an entity owned in whole or in part by his or her IRA. Although the tax law generally provides an exception for reasonable compensation paid by an IRA, the exception does not apply to compensation for services rendered by an IRA owner to an entity wholly or partially owned by the IRA. (Ellis v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2013-245.) See Chapter 5 of the treatise.
Publicly Traded Grantor Trust Holding Gold. – The acquisition of a “collectible” by an IRA is subject to harsh treatment for tax purposes. A retiree or beneficiary must treat the cost or value of the collectible as an immediate taxable distribution. Collectibles generally include gold coins and gold bullion. However, the IRS has ruled that publicly traded shares of a grantor trust holding gold coins and gold bullion are generally not collectibles. (Ltr. Rul. 201446030.) See Chapter 5 of the treatise.
The Trustee of an IRA May Refuse to Invest in Certain Types of Assets. – A retiree cannot compel an IRA to invest in types of assets not authorized by the IRA instrument or allowed by the trustee. For example, the Tax Court has held a distribution to be taxable even though the taxpayer invested the distribution in real estate that he titled in his name as agent for the IRA. The distribution was taxable because the IRA trustee refused to accept real estate as an IRA asset. (Dabney v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2014-108.) See Chapter 5 of the treatise.
Treatment of a Spouse’s Community Property Interest in an IRA Distribution to a Nonspousal Beneficiary. – The IRS has ruled that an IRA distribution to a nonspousal beneficiary may be taxable to the beneficiary even though the surviving spouse has enforceable property rights in the distributed funds under state community property laws. Proper planning for this anomaly might involve either (1) a lifetime conversion of the spouse’s community property rights into the separate property of the retiree or (2) designation of the surviving spouse as an IRA beneficiary to the extent of his or her community property rights. Or after decedent’s death, the nonspousal beneficiary might make a timely disclaimer of the IRA to the extent of the spouse’s community property interest. (Priv. Ltr. Rul. 201623001.) See Chapter 5 of the treatise for a discussion of community property interests in IRAs.
Rollovers to Simple IRAs Now Generally Allowed. – A taxpayer may now roll over distributions tax-free into a Simple IRA from other IRAs and tax-favored retirement plans, but only after expiration of the two-year period following the taxpayer’s first participation in a Simple IRA. During the same two-year period, the taxpayer may roll over a distribution from a Simple IRA only to another Simple IRA. (IRC § 408(p)(1)(B).) See Chapter 5 of the treatise.